The Problem with Leadership Development “Programs”
Wednesday, June 30th, 2010The question then becomes, If leadership is so critical to an organization’s success (and research is bearing this out through a number of studies) then the question becomes why are not more organizations taking the bull by the horn? Bottom line, it is the legacy experience most organizations have had with leadership development “programs.” They have far from lived up to their promise.
The reason for the failure of the “Leadership Development Program Model” is because such programs are not linked to the business. After all exceptional leaders always have better results than nominal leaders because they are leading the business! Given that why do we separate development from moving forward business objectives? We have done this for years and then when you need to cut costs – we cut development. Why because there is no clear connection between leadership development programs and important outcomes of a business.
So how do we fix this? In short we fix it by starting by looking at the state of the business and examine the gaps between where we are are and where we want to be. Then we look at leadership as one of the parameters for closing that gap. The top team must then look at who it has to be individually and collectively in order to close the gap and then we must fuse the desired business outcomes with the leadership development process we engage. If that is done we don’t have a “program” but rather an initiative to support greater business success.
The reason why executive coaching has been so successful and has seen such a strong return on investment is that most executive coaches worth their weight engage the leader at the level of desired results and design their executive coaching around improving those results. Along the way guess what? Developmental gaps show up through the coaching experience that must be addressed in order to achieve the desired outcomes. The outcome - you get better business results as well as a leader who has greater impact. It has a multiplying effect. Yet, as much as executive coaching is a useful process – it works at the individual level – rarely at the collective level. We need to take this understanding to a strategic level for an organization and build approaches that focus on the business results first while also supporting transforming leadership.
Therefore, if someone comes to your organization promoting “programs” be leery! Ask them how is this going to improve my outcomes? If they can’t show you how that will occur do not consider hiring them!






